My sight : X-Factor Indonesia VS The Voice of Indonesia

Assalamualaikum , Best wishes for us (always) 

Hi friends, how's your life? I hope all of you always in an awesome condition.

Okay, now I'll give my view points toward X-Factor Indonesia and The Voice of Indonesia. I believe you know about them, don't you?

As we know, X-Factor Indonesia and The Voice of Indonesia are the  singing-talented programs that have recently aired in Indonesia's television. X-Factor Indonesia in RCTI, while The Voice of Indonesia in Indosiar.It seems that RCTI and Indosiar will compete to  get as much as attention from the audiences. Let's see which one will be the greatest singing-talented program.Okay, both of them are adopted-program. Hopefully, those programs will "born" the great singers to fulfill the music-industry in Indonesia. Moreover, those programs entertain Indonesian who feel tired with the political/education/security and the human rights issues in Indonesia ( Oh my , my words seems to be a little bit serious) , hahha.

Yappz, as a singing-talented program' viewer, I would like to compare the XFI (X-Factor Indonesia) and TVI ( The Voice of Indonesia) based on the audition concept , the judges, and the participants.

Okay don't make it too platitudinous , make it to the point , hahahha, Yapzzz, here are they :

1. The audition concept

In my opinion,concept is very important in every program/event. Without awesome concept, there won't be a superb program. An extraordinary concept will attract the viewer/audience to watch and appreciate the program.  In this case, I'll discuss about the audition concept,the XFI and TVI concept are great. However, there is a slightly different concept in those two program. 

In the XFI , the concept is simple, if you have ever watched it, you will see the participant enter the stage --> introduce his/her name--> and the judges can have a free conversation with him/her--> he/she starts singing--> he/she finishes singing --> the judges give comments of his/her performance--> the judges decide if the participat will continue /  be accepted  or not, and the judges will say "YES" if they accept the participant' performance. 

On the other hand, TVI's concept is extraordinary, last night ( Feb 10th at 8 PM) when I watched it ,I suprised , Ooooo the concept differed from another program, it's great anyway. Did you watched TVI? , if not , here is it the audition flow --> the judges sit in their chair with the words "I WANT YOU" in the chairs ( you can see the picture  above to make it clear) , and at first the judges can't see the stage for a while ( because the chairs turn around )--> the participant enters in the stage and starts singing --> the judges only listen his/her voice --> if the judges like his/her voice , the judges will press the button in their chair and the lamp in the words " I WANT YOU" will on --> the judges' chairs will turn around again, so that the judges  can see the stage (the participant) --> the judges ask the participants' identity , and ask them to choose who will be their tentor ( to make the song project together) --> each judge give promise/ persuade the chosen participants so the participant will certain with their decision. 

2. The Judges 

XFI' judges

TVI' judges

If we talk about the judges , we will think about their credibility  Yapz, in my humble opinion, the judges in XFI and TVI are all credible bacause they have excellence background knowledge in music industry. Let's take a look , in XFI, the judges are Ahmad Dhani, Bebi Romeo, Rossa, and Anggun. Whereas in TVI , the judges are Armand Maulana, Giring, Glen, and Sherina. Both of the programs have 4 judges to judge the participants' performance. However, the TVI judges will offer the team-music project with the chosen participants (they'll make music project together) , while  the XFI' judges only become the mentor of the participants. Once more , maybe  in the next episodes, those programs also use sms polling. Let's see. 

3. The participants

Furthermore,participants also attracted my attention to watch those programs. There are so many kinds of participants in those programs. As long as I watched the programs, In XFI ;there are so many varied participants ( solo, duo, vocal group , acapella) with the different ages (from the 15-80 years old). Besides, some of them also have awesome voices when they are singing. While , in TVI , the participans are solo  ( based on my observation when I watched it last night-February 10th ) and of course their voices are also great.

Yapzzz, these are my view points about the audition concept, the judges , and the participants. Personally , I like The Voice of Indonesia' audition concept because it's unique and fresh concept. Then, for the judges , I like both of them, the Voice of Indonesia and X-Factor, because they have "to the point" comments. Here I go, for the participants , Damn I like X-Factor' participants , because they can entertain  more ( great singing, unique, varied participants). If you don't agree with mine, it's okay . I think you have yours , don't you? 

All in all , these are my opinion , How about you? Which one do you prefer? 

X-Factor Indonesia or The Voice of Indonesia? 

Thanks a ton for reading My sight : X-Factor Indonesia VS The Voice of Indonesia.

Wassalamualaikum. God bless you all.